The Soviet Factor in the US-China Military-Technical Cooperation during the Cold War

The development of the PRC’s armed forces included three phases when their modernization was carried out through an active introduction of foreign weapons and technologies. The first and the last of these phases (from 1949 to 1961, and from 1992 till present) received wide attention in both Chinese and Western academic literature, whereas the second one — from 1978 to 1989 —when the PRC actively purchased weapons and technologies from the Western countries remains somewhat understudied. This paper is intended to partially fill this gap. The author examines the logic of the military-technical cooperation between the PRC and the United States in the context of complex interactions within the United States — the USSR — China strategic triangle in the last years of the Cold War. The first section covers early contacts between the PRC and the United States in the security field — from the visit of R. Nixon to China till the inauguration of R. Reagan. The author shows that during this period Washington clearly subordinated the US-Chinese cooperation to the development of the US-Soviet relations out of fear to damage the fragile process of detente. The second section focuses on the evolution of the R. Reagan administration’s approaches regarding arms sales to China in the context of a new round of the Cold War. The Soviet factor significantly influenced the development of the US-Chinese military-technical cooperation during that period, which for both parties acquired not only practical, but, most importantly, political importance. It was their mutual desire to undermine strategic positions of the USSR that allowed these two countries to overcome successfully tensions over the US arms sales to Taiwan. However, this dependence of the US-China military-technical cooperation on the Soviet factor had its downside. As the third section shows, with the Soviet threat fading away, the main incentives for the military-technical cooperation between the PRC and the United States also disappeared. As a result, after the Tiananmen Square protests, this cooperation completely ceased. Thus, the author concludes that the US arms sales to China from the very beginning were conditioned by the dynamics of the Soviet-American relations and Beijing’s willingness to play an active role in the policy of containment. In that regard, the very fact of the US arms sales to China was more important than its practical effect, i.e. this cooperation was of political nature, rather than military one.

1. Galenovich Yu. M. 2011. Istoriya vzaimootnoshenii Rossii i Kitaya: V 4 kn. Kn. 3. Odin stroi — dva gosudarstva (1949-1991 gg.) [History of relations between Russia and China: In 4 books. Book 3. One regime — two states (1949-1991)]. Moscow, Russkaya panorama Publ. (In Russ.)

2. Khasanov R. Sh., Lobov V. N. 2016. ‘Zapad-81’ — uroki i vyvody: Interv’yu s doktorom voennykh nauk, professorom, generalom armii Vladimirom Nikolaevichem Lobovym [‘Zapad-81’ — Lessons and conclusions: Interview with Army General Vladimir Nikolaevich Lobov]. Voennyi akademicheskii zhurnal, no. 3, pp. 64-71. (In Russ.)

3. Khritoshin I. A. 2014. Terminologicheskaya identifikatsiya vooruzheniya i voennoi tekhniki [Terminological identification of arms and military equipment]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta MVD Rossii, no. 3, pp. 126-128. (In Russ.)

4. Ali S. M. 2007. US-China Cold War collaboration: 1971-1989. London, Routledge.

5. Bitzinger R. 1991. Chinese arms production and sales to the Third World. Santa Monica, RAND.

6. Chand A. 1989. Defence modernization, secret deals, and strategy of nations (A global study of army, navy, airforce, and para-military forces). Part 1. New Delhi, Mittal Publications.

7. Chu W. 1986. Increased military sales to China: Problems and prospects. Journal of International Affairs, vol. 39, no. 2, pp. 133-147.

8. Chyba C. F. 1981. U. S. military-support equipment sales to the People’s Republic of China. Asian Survey, vol. 21, no. 4, pp. 469-484.

9. Dai C. 2010. Mei guo ‘mao yi zi you hua’ zheng ce yu zhong guo ‘gai ge kai fang’ (1969-1975) [US ‘trade liberalization’ and China’s ‘reform and opening’ policies (1969-1975)]. Shi xue yue kan, no. 2, pp. 83-104. (In Chinese).

10. Dumbaugh K. B., Grimmett R. F. 1986. Arms sales to China: The limits to U.S.-Chinese military cooperation. The Washington Quarterly, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 89-99.

11. Fardella E. 2009. The Sino-American normalization: A reassessment. Diplomatic History, vol. 33, no. 4, pp. 545-578.

12. Gaddis J. L. 1981. Containment: Its past and future. International Security, vol. 5, no. 4. pp. 74-102.

13. Gaddis J. L. 1982. Strategies of containment: A critical appraisal of postwar American national security policy. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

14. Gao W. 2003. Wan nian Zhou Enlai [Zhou Enlai in his old age]. Hong Kong, Ming jing chu ban she. (In Chinese).

15. Gill B., Kim T. 1995. China’s arms acquisitions from abroad: A quest for ‘superb and secret weapons’. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

16. Harding H. 1992. A fragile relationship: The United States and China since 1972. Washington, D. C., Brookings Institution Press.

17. Jia H. 1984. Mei guan yuan he bao jie tan xiang wo chu shou jun shi zhuang bei wen ti [US officials and press talk about the sale of military equipment to us]. Guo ji wen ti zi liao, no. 4, pp. 16-18. (In Chinese).

18. Jun S. 1997. Zhong guo ren min jie fang jun de qi shi nian [70 years of the People’s Liberation Army of China]. Beijing, Jun shi ke xue chu ban she. (In Chinese).

19. Liu L., Ma X. 2015. Zhong mei jian jiao chu qi liang guo jun shi yu an quan he zuo de chu bu fa zhan [The preliminary development of U.S.-China military and security cooperation in the late 1970s]. Zhong gong dang shi yan jiu, no. 4, pp. 63-72. (In Chinese).

20. Meijer H. 2016. Trading with the enemy: The making of US export control policy toward the People’s Republic of China. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

21. Richelson J. 1995. The U. S. intelligence community. Boulder, Westview Press.

22. Ross M. C. 1986. China and the United States’ export controls system. Columbia Journal of World Business, vol. 21, no. 1, pp. 27-33.

23. Ross R. S. 1995. Negotiating cooperation: The United States and China, 1969-1989. Redwood City, Stanford University Press.

24. Tao W. 2004. Zhongmeiguan xi shi [History of the U. S.-China relations]. Shanghai, Shanghai People’s Publishing House. (In Chinese).

25. Woon E. Y. 1989. Chinese arms sales and U. S.-China military relations. Asian Survey, vol. 29, no. 6, pp. 601-618.

26. Xin Y. 2016. Ka te zheng fu de dui hua ji shu zhuan rang yu jun shou zheng ce [The transfer of civil high tech equipment and military equipment to the PRC under the Carter administration]. Mei guo yan jiu, no. 5, pp. 126-146. (In Chinese).

27. Xin Y. 2018. Lun li gen zheng fu shi qi mei guo dui hua ji shu zhuan rang yu jun shou [On America’s technology transfer and arms sale to China during the Reagan administration period]. Dang dai zhong guo shi yan jiu, no. 1, pp. 91-98. (In Chinese).

28. Yang Z. 2004. Hei ying de man chang zheng tu [The long march o f‘Black Hawk’]. Guo ji zhan wang, no. 16, pp. 22-25. (In Chinese).

29. Yuan F., Wang X. 2016. Kai chu guo men — 86 bu bing che yan sheng de wai mao xing hao [For foreign market — the export model of INV Type 86]. Bing qi, no. 12, pp. 71-74. (In Chinese).

30. Zubok V. 2017. The Soviet Union and China in the 1980s: Reconciliation and divorce. Cold War History, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 121-141.