At the Turn of the Nuclear Ages: Strategic Stability and Contours of a New World Order

The year 2018 is rich with anniversaries. In the current international context the 50^th anniversary of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty is certainly having special relevance. However, in the view of the need to examine the prospects of ensuring strategic stability, the role of nuclear weapons in world politics and the contours of the new world order yet another anniversary – twenty years from the beginning of the ‘second nuclear age’ – is just as important. In order to identify the substantive aspects of this phenomenon this paper provides a comparative analysis of distinctive features of both the first and the second nuclear ages. The author identifies the causes and prerequisites for the beginning of the ‘first nuclear age’ and examines, on the basis of a wide range of policy papers and analytical reports, the evolution of the United States’ approaches to nuclear strategy, deterrence and military and political goal setting. Special focus is on such issues as the achievement of strategic parity between the Soviet Union and the United States and the role of the Strategic Arms Limitation Talks Agreement and the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty in the development of the concept of strategic stability and informal code of conduct of nuclear powers. The paper emphasizes that although the ‘first nuclear age’ coincides chronologically with the Cold War, these two phenomena are not identical. As for the ‘second nuclear age’, the author links its emergence with such developments as India and Pakistan joining the nuclear ‘club’, long-range missile tests carried out by the DPRK, and the revision of the U.S. policy regarding the anti-missile defense which led to the abrogation of the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty. The author concludes that defining characteristics of the ‘second nuclear age’ include the retention of the ‘central deterrence’ accompanied by a growing importance of new political formats involving both nuclear and non-nuclear states, many of which have culturally specific approaches to military policy and strategic planning. All these factors combined form a backbone of military and political interactions between the leading powers within the emerging world order.

1. Brodie B. 1961. Strategy in the missile age. Princeton, Princeton University Press [Russ. ed.: Brodi B. 1961. Strategiya v vek raketnogo oruzhiya. Moscow, Voenizdat Publ.].

2. Kaufmann W.W. (ed.). 1956. Military policy and national security. Princeton, Princeton University Press [Russ. ed.: Voennaya politika i natsional’naya bezopasnost’. 1958. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo inostrannoi literatury Publ.].

3. Dean G. 1957. Vvedenie [Introduction]. In Kissinger H.A. Nuclear weapons and foreign policy. New York, Published for the Council on Foreign Relations by Harper [Russ. ed.: Kissinger H. 1959. Yadernoe oruzhie i vneshnyaya politika. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo inostrannoi literatury Publ.], pp. 33–37.

4. Douhet G. 1936. Gospodstvo v vozdukhe [Command of the air]. Moscow, Voenizdat NKO SSSR Publ. (In Russ.)

5. Zhuravlev A.L., Nestik T.A., Sosnin V.A. 2016. Sotsial’no-psikhologicheskie aspekty geopoliticheskoi stabil’nosti i yadernogo sderzhivaniya v XXI veke [Social and psychological components of the geopolitical stability and nuclear deterrence in the XXI century’]. Moscow, Institut psikhologii RAN Publ. (In Russ.)

6. Kahn H. 1965. On escalation: Metaphors and scenarios. New York, Frederick A. Praeger [Russ. ed.: Kan G. 1966. Ob eskalatsii. Moscow, Voenizdat Publ.].

7. Kissinger H.A. 1957. Nuclear weapons and foreign policy. New York, Published for the Council on Foreign Relations by Harper [Russ. ed.: Kissinger H. 1959. Yadernoe oruzhie i vneshnyaya politika. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo inostrannoi literatury Publ.].

8. Clausewitz C. 1934. O voine [On war]. Moscow, Gosvoenizdat Publ. (In Russ.)

9. Kokoshin A.A. 1988. Razvitie voennogo dela i sokrashchenie vooruzhennykh sil i obychnykh vooruzhenii [Development of military art and the reduction of armed forces and conventional armaments]. Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, no. 1, pp. 20–32. (In Russ.)

10. Kokoshin A.A. 1999. Yadernoe sderzhivanie i natsional’naya bezopasnost’ Rossii [Nuclear deterrence and Russia’s national security]. Vestnik Rossiiskoi akademii nauk, no. 10, pp. 893–904. (In Russ.).

11. Kokoshin A.A. 2003. Yadernye konflikty v XXI veke (tipy, formy, vozmozhnye uchastniki) [Nuclear conflicts in the XXI century: Types, forms, and potential participants]. Moscow, Media-Press Publ. (In Russ.).

12. Kokoshin A.A., Veselov V.A., Liss A.V. 2001. Sderzhivanie vo ‘vtorom yadernom veke’ [Deterrence in the ‘second nuclear age’]. Moscow, IPMB RAN Publ. (In Russ.)

13. Osgood R.E. 1957. Limited war: The challenge to American strategy. Chicago, University of Chicago Press [Osgud R. 1960. Ogranichennaya voina. Moscow, Voenizdat Publ.].

14. Savel’ev A.G. 2013. O mnogostoronnem podkhode k probleme yadernogo razoruzheniya [On multilateral approach to nuclear disarmament]. In Ivanov I.S. (ed.). O mnogostoronnem podkhode k probleme yadernogo razoruzheniya, no. IX [On multilateral approach to nuclear disarmament]. Moscow, Spetskniga Publ., pp. 4–15. (In Russ.)

15. Svechin A.A. 1926. Bazirovanie i udarnost’ [Deployment and strike potential]. In Svechin A.A. (ed.). Strategiya v trudakh voennykh klassikov [Strategy in works of military classics]. Vol. 2. Moscow, Gosudarstvennoe voennoe izdatel’stvo Publ., pp. 7–20. (In Russ.)

16. Sun Tzu. 1995. Traktat o voennom iskusstve [The art of war]. In Konrad N.I. Sinologiya [Sinology]. Moscow, Ladomir Publ., pp. 14–284. (In Russ.)

17. Fenenko A.V., Veselov V.A. ‘Vozdushnaya moshch’ v mirovoi politike [‘Airpower’ in international politics]. Mezhdunarodnye protsessy, vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 6–27. (In Russ.)

18. Schelling Th. 1960. The strategy of conflict. Cambridge, Harvard University Press [Russ. ed.: Shelling T. 2007. Strategiya konflikta. Moscow, IRISEN Publ.].

19. Brodie B. et al. (eds.). 1946. The absolute weapon: Atomic power and world order. New York, Harcourt, Brace and Company.

20. Paul T.V., Harknett R.J., Wirtz J.J. (eds.). 1998. The absolute weapon revisited: Nuclear arms and the emerging international order. Ann Arbor, University of Michigan Press.

21. Arnett E.H. 1994. Deterrence after nuclear proliferation: Implications for nuclear forces and defense spending. The Nonproliferation Review, vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 10–17.

22. Tellis A.J., Denmark A.M., Tanner T. (eds.). 2013. Asia in the second nuclear age. Seattle, The National Bureau of Asian Research.

23. Betts R.K. 1988. Nuclear peace and conventional war. The Journal of Strategic Studies, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 79–95.

24. Bracken P. 1999. Fire in the East: The rise of Asian military power and the second nuclear age. New York, HarperCollins.

25. Bracken P. 2000. The second nuclear age. Foreign Affairs, no. 1, pp. 146–156.

26. Bracken P. 2012. The second nuclear age: Strategy, danger, and the new power politics. New York, Henry Holt and Co.

27. Bracken P. 2003. The structure of the second nuclear age. Orbis, vol. 47, no. 3, pp. 399–413.

28. Brodie B. 1958. The anatomy of deterrence. Santa Monica, RAND Corporation, RM-2218.

29. Brodie B. 1966. Escalation and the nuclear option. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

30. Brodie B. 1946. War in the atomic age. In Brodie B et al. (eds.). The absolute weapon: Atomic power and world order. New York, Harcourt, Brace and Company.

31. Brooks L., Gavin F.J., Arbatov A. 2018. Meeting the challenges of the new nuclear age: U.S. and Russian nuclear concepts, past and present. American Academy of Arts & Sciences. Available at: https://www.amacad.org/multimedia/pdfs/publications/researchpapersmonographs/New-Nuclear-Age.pdf (accessed: 12.02.2018).

32. Brooks L., Rapp-Hooper M. 2013. Extended deterrence, assurance, and reassurance in the Pacific during the second nuclear age. In Tellis A.J., Denmark A.M., Tanner T. (eds.). Asia in the second nuclear age. Seattle, The National Bureau of Asian Research, pp. 267–299.

33. Broscious S.D. 1999. Longing for international control, banking on American superiority: Harry S. Truman’s approach to nuclear weapons. In Gaddis J.L. (ed.). Cold War statesmen confront the bomb: Nuclear diplomacy since 1945. Oxford; New York, Oxford University Press, pp. 15–38.

34. Cha V. 2001. The second nuclear age: Proliferation pessimism versus sober optimism in South Asia and East Asia. Journal of Strategic Studies, vol. 24, no. 4, pp. 79–120.

35. Clearwater J.M. 1996. Johnson, McNamara, and the birth of SALT and the ABM Treaty 1963–1969. Universal-Publishers.

36. Curatola J.M. 2016. Bigger bombs for a brighter tomorrow: The Strategic Air Command and American war plans at the dawn of the atomic age, 1945–1950. Jefferson, McFarland & Company.

37. Daugherty W., Levi B., Von Hippel F. 1986. The consequences of ‘limited’ nuclear attacks on the United States. International Security, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 3–45.

38. Ferguson Ch.D., MacDonald B.W. 2017. Nuclear dynamics in a multipolar strategic ballistic missile defense world. Federation of American Scientists. Available at: https://fas.org/wp-content/uploads/media/Nuclear-Dynamics-InA-Multipolar-Strategic-Ballistic-Missile-Defense-World.pdf (accessed: 12.12.2017).

39. Freedman L. 2003. The evolution of nuclear strategy. 3rd ed. New York, Palgrave Macmillan.

40. Freedman L. 1998. The revolution in strategic affairs. London; New York, Oxford University Press for the International Institute for Strategic Studies.

41. Garcia Z. 2017. Strategic stability in the twenty-first century: The challenge of the second nuclear age and the logic of stability interdependence. Comparative Strategy, vol. 36, no. 4, pp. 354–365.

42. Gerson M.S. 2009. Conventional deterrence in the second nuclear age. Parameters, vol. 39, no. 3, pp. 32–48.

43. Gray C.S. 1999. The second nuclear age. Boulder, Lynne Rienner Publishers.

44. Halperin M.H. 1963. Limited war in the nuclear age. New York, Wiley.

45. Halperin M.H. 1961. Nuclear weapons and limited war. Journal of Conflict Resolution, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 146–166.

46. Herken G. 1988. The winning weapon: The atomic bomb in the Cold War, 1945–1950. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

47. Huntington S.P. 1983. Conventional deterrence and conventional retaliation in Europe. International Security, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 32–56.

48. Iklé F.Ch. 1996. The second coming of the nuclear age. Foreign Affairs, vol. 74, no. 1, pp. 119–128.

49. Kahn H. 1961. On thermonuclear war. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

50. Kampani G. 2014. China–India nuclear rivalry in the ‘second nuclear age’. Oslo, The Norwegian Institute for Defense Studies.

51. Kampani G., Gopalaswamy B. 2017. Asia in the ‘second nuclear age’. Atlantic Council.

52. Kaplan E. 2015. To kill nations: American strategy in the air-atomic age and the rise of mutually assured destruction. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.

53. Kaplan M.A. 1958. The calculus of deterrence. World Politics, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 20–44.

54. Kaplan M.A. 1959. The strategy of limited retaliation. Princeton University, Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs, Center of International Studies. Policy memorandum No. 19. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

55. Katz А. 1982. Life after nuclear war: The economic and social impacts of nuclear attacks on the United States. Cambridge, MA, Ballinger Pub. Co.

56. Katz A., Osdoby S.R. 1982. The social and economic effects of nuclear war. CATO Institute Policy Analysis, no. 9. Available at: https://object.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa009.pdf (accessed: 17.12.2017).

57. Kaufmann W.W. 1958. The evolution of deterrence 1945–1958. Santa Monica, RAND Corporation.

58. Kaufmann W.W. 1954. The requirements of deterrence. Princeton University, Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs, Center of International Studies. Memorandum No. 7. Princeton, Princeton University, Center of International Studies.

59. Kent G.A., Ochmanek D., Spirtas M., Pirnie B.R. 2008. Thinking about America’s defense: An analytical memoir. Santa Monica, RAND Corporation.

60. Kissinger Н.A. 1960. The necessity for choice: Prospects of American foreign policy. New-York, Harper and Brothers.

61. Knorr K. 1966. On the uses of military power in the nuclear age. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

62. Koblentz G.D. 2014. Strategic stability in the second nuclear age. Council on Foreign Relations. Special Report No. 71. Available at: https://www.cfr.org/sites/default/files/pdf/2014/11/Second%20Nuclear%20Age_CSR71.pdf (accessed: 17.12.2017).

63. Krepinevich A.F. 2009. US nuclear forces: Meeting the challenge of a proliferated world. Washington, D.C., Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments.

64. Krepon M. 2009. Numerology in the second nuclear age. IFRI Proliferation Papers, no. 30. Available at: https://www.ifri.org/en/publications/enotes/proliferation-papers/numerology-second-nuclear-age (accessed: 17.12.2017).

65. Lavoy P.R. 1995. The strategic consequences of nuclear proliferation: A review essay. Security Studies, vol. 4, no. 4, pp. 695–753.

66. Levite A.E. 2009. Heading for the fourth nuclear age. IFRI Proliferation Papers, no. 24. Available at: https://www.ifri.org/en/publications/enotes/proliferation-papers/heading-fourth-nuclear-age (accessed: 17.12.2017).

67. Knorr K., Read Th. (eds.). 1962. Limited strategic war. New York: Published for the Center of International Studies, Princeton University, by Praeger.

68. Marlo F.H. 2012. Planning Reagan’s war: Conservative strategists and America’s Cold War victory. Washington, D.C., Potomac Books.

69. Mearsheimer J.J. 1983. Conventional deterrence. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.

70. Mearsheimer J.J. 1982. Why the Soviets can’t win quickly in central Europe. International Security, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 3–39.

71. Mills M., Toon O., Lee-Taylor J., Robock A. 2014. Multi-decadal global cooling and unprecedented ozone loss following a regional nuclear conflict. Earth’s Future, vol. 2, no. 4, pp. 161–176.

72. Montgomery E. 2016. Extended deterrence in the second nuclear age. Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments. Available at: http://csbaonline.org/uploads/documents/CSBA6183-ExtendedDeterrence_PRINT.pdf (accessed: 17.12.2017).

73. Narang V. 2014. Nuclear strategy in the modern era: Regional powers and international conflict. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

74. Payne K.B. 1996. Deterrence in the second nuclear age. Lexington, University Press of Kentucky.

75. Rearden S.L. 1998. US strategic bombardment doctrine since 1945. In Cargill Hall R. (ed.). Case studies in strategic bombardment. Washington, D.C., Air Force Historical Studies Office, pp. 383–467.

76. Richelson J. 1983. PD-59, NSDD-13 and the Reagan strategic modernization program. The Journal of Strategic Studies, vol. 6. no. 2, pp. 125–146.

77. Robock A., Oman L., Stenchikov G.L. 2007. Nuclear winter revisited with a modern climate model and current nuclear arsenals: Still catastrophic consequences. Journal of Geophysical Research. Atmospheres, vol. 112, no. D13107, pp. 1–14.

78. Robock A., Toon O. 2012. Self-assured destruction: The climate impacts of nuclear war. Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, vol. 68, no. 5, pp. 66–74.

79. Rosenberg D.A. 1983. The origins of overkill: Nuclear weapons and American strategy, 1945–1960. International Security, vol. 7, no. 4, pp. 3–71.

80. Rühle M. 2007. Enlightenment in the second nuclear age. International Affairs, vol. 83, no. 3, pp. 511–522.

81. Sagan S.D. 1989. Moving targets: Nuclear strategy and American security. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

82. Sagan S.D. 1987. SIOP-62: The nuclear war plan briefing to President Kennedy. International Security, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 22–51.

83. Sagan S.D., Waltz K.N. 1995. The spread of nuclear weapons: A debate. New York, W.W. Norton.

84. Schelling Th. 1966. Arms and influence. New Haven, Yale University Press.

85. Schnabel J.F. 1996. History of the Joint Chiefs of Staff: The Joint Chiefs of Staff and national policy. Vol. 1. 1945–1947. Washington, D.C., Office of the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Available at: http://www.jcs.mil/Portals/36/Documents/History/Policy/Policy_V001.pdf (accessed: 17.12.2017).

86. Snyder G.H. 1961. Deterrence and defense: Toward a theory of national security. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

87. Snyder G.H. 1960. Deterrence and power. Journal of Conflict Resolution, vol. 6, no. 3, pp. 163–178.

88. Snyder G.H. 1959. Deterrence by denial and punishment. Princeton University, Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs, Center of International Studies, Research monograph No. 40. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

89. Yoshihara T., Holmes J.R. (eds.). 2012. Strategy in the second nuclear age: Power, ambition, and the ultimate weapon. Georgetown University Press.

90. Wellerstein A. 2016. The psychological power of nuclear weapons. Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, vol. 72, no. 5, pp. 298–303.

91. Wohlstetter A.J. 1958. The delicate balance of terror. Santa Monica, RAND Corporation, P-1472. Available at: https://www.rand.org/pubs/papers/P1472.html (accessed: 12.12.2017).